May 12, 2017

Why index investing is best for most, but stock picking reigns supreme for some with Motley Fool co-founder Tom Gardner, who has a track record to prove it.

WEALTHTRACK Episode #1347; Originally Broadcast on May 12, 2017

Listen to the audio only version here:

Explore This Episode

We have compiled additional information and content related to this episode.


Consuelo Mack

We have been receiving many emails from viewers about the merits of passive versus active investing, a topic we have been covering over the years, but more frequently recently as more research comes in.

A lot of people threw in the towel on active when they heard the results of the latest SPIVA U.S. Scorecard report from S&P Dow Jones Indices.  It presents the 15-year track record for domestic equity funds – and the report notes: “The longer time horizon provides a complete market cycle to measure effectiveness of managers across all categories.”

The figures were stark:  92% of large-cap U.S. stock fund managers, 95% of mid-cap, and 93% of small-cap managers trailed their respective benchmarks.

The comparisons didn’t improve when you traveled overseas either. The majority of managers across all international equity categories underperformed their benchmarks as well.

Another stunning trend was how many funds disappeared over the 15-year period. More than 58% of domestic equity funds were either merged or liquidated and almost 52% of global/international equity funds were.

Is the case now closed? Does passive win?  This week’s WEALTHTRACK guest, Tom Gardner, is a successful active manager who believes passive is best for most, but active rules for some, especially those attracted to The Motley Fool investing community.  Gardner is CEO and Co-Founder (with his older brother David), of The Motley Fool which they started as a small printed newsletter for family and friends in 1993.  They turned it into a website, the fool.com in 1994.  Now it is an international multi-media network offering financial services to millions of individuals through its website, podcasts, books, newsletters, columns, and wealth management services.

Their flagship Stock Advisor portfolio, which they write about in their monthly newsletter, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has crushed the S&P 500 since its 2002 inception with 17.8% annualized total returns vs. the market’s 7%. It combines Tom’s more conservative value approach and David’s swing for the fences growth approach. Both brothers believe in investing in great businesses with strong financials, managements and cultures. Motley Fool itself was ranked the number one place to work in the U.S. for small and medium sized companies in 2014 and 2015.

Before discussing how he identifies individual companies to invest in for years, I will ask Gardner why his first piece of advice for new Motley Fool investors is “Buy an index fund!”

As always, if you miss the show on Public Television, you can watch it at your convenience on our website.  You’ll also find my weekly Action Points there, plus our guests’ “One Investment” ideas.  Also, in his EXTRA interview on our website, Gardner explains why he thinks the future of financial advice will come from apps, not humans.

My best wishes to all of you for a happy Mother’s Day weekend!  Thank you for watching, and make the week ahead a profitable and a productive one.

Best regards,

Mathews Asia


  • Do they act as fiduciaries, putting clients’ interests first?
  • Do they have a clearly stated mission and investment objectives?
  • Are they committed to disciplined investing for the long term, built to last?
  • Are they cost conscious?
  • Are they honest about mistakes and humble about their successes?

The Motley Fool Investment Guide: How The Fool Beats Wall Street’s Wise Men And How You Can Too
The Motley Fool Investment Guide for Teens: 8 Steps to Having More Money Than Your Parents Ever Dreamed Of


  • Paycom Software Inc (PAYC)
  • Price: $64.47 on 5/9/17
  • 52-week range: $37.15 – $65.39

PAYC Chart

PAYC data by YCharts

Facebook Inc (FB)
FB Chart

FB data by YCharts

Shopify Inc (SHOP)
SHOP Chart

SHOP data by YCharts

Fitbit Inc (FIT)
FIT Chart

FIT data by YCharts

Arista Networks Inc (ANET)
ANET Chart

ANET data by YCharts

Whole Foods Market Inc (WFM)
WFM Chart

WFM data by YCharts

WEALTHTRACK PREMIUM subscribers can access your copy here, otherwise this transcript is available here for purchase.

More information regarding WEALTHTRACK transcripts can be found here

The Gardner brothers from the WEALTHTRACK Archives:

If the archive episodes do not appear here, please turn off, or whitelist this site, in your ad blocker extension.


Tom Gardner was a pioneer in offering investment advice online with The Motley Fool.  He is now predicting the future of financial advice overall will come from apps not humans and he says that future is upon us.

Tagged with:

Back to Top